I got the idea for this post by reading CDF Networks blog. Chad did some really cool tests where he tested and rated a bunch of PPC networks. I haven’t seen anyone do this for PPV networks so I thought I would do one.

The test:

I ran 4 offers on each of these networks. Actually it was 2 separate offers but one campaign used a landing page, and one direct linked. I promoted pretty basic lead generation offers. I kept all the URL/keyword targets the same, and tried to be in the same as position on each network. For the sake of simplicity I am calling these ‘PPV networks’ even though that’s not the technically correct term for some of them. Basically, they are all serving ads in the form of a pop-up or pop-under window.

Scoring:

For scoring, I used traffic volume, conversion rate,  and click/impression pricing broken down like this:

  • Traffic Volume (Most traffic= 10, least traffic = 1)
  • Conversion Rate (Highest Conversions= 10, least conversions = 1)
  • Click Pricing ( lowest click/impressions cost = 10)

So basically a perfect score would be 30.

Here are the results:

PPV Networks

Results

The overall winner was Traffic Vance which won’t come as a surprise to most of you. Megaclick has a lot of traffic but it was very expensive.

Conversion Rate:

Both Traffic Vance and Media Traffic had a high conversion rate. The one thing missing from Media Traffic is more volume.

Recommended:

  • Traffic Vance
  • Media Traffic
  • Lead Impact
  • Addon Network
  • Direct CPV

Might be worth a small test:

  • CPV Marketplace
  • Megaclick

Stay away:

  • Adbrite
  • Clicksor

I want to stress that different PPV/CPV networks can perform better/worse for different offers. Your results could vary based on the offers you promote.


Share This Post...Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInPin on PinterestShare on RedditShare on StumbleUponBuffer this page